"With the information we have accumulated, we can now move forward with a
comprehensive plan to open up important spawning and rearing habitat for
salmon," said Reuven Walder, SPAWN watershed biologist, and primary author
of the report. "These areas of our creeks have been blocked for decades by
culverts, small dams, and other structures."
Thirteen creeks in the San Geronimo Valley were surveyed and 31 culverts, 12
dams, and 10 miscellaneous structures were identified for removal, according
to Walder. The thirteen tributaries include Willis Evans Canyon, Deer Camp
Canyon, Cremery, Larsen, Blueline, Arroyo, Barranca, El Cerrito, Montezuma,
Sintura and Barnabe creeks.
The San Geronimo Valley suffers from the burgeoning demands on water and
land that other communities throughout California encounter as a result of
increasing urbanization. The valley now has 330 residents on 1500 parcels
of land, including 200 located rights along the creeks.
The Lagunitas Creek Watershed is one of the most important remaining
habitats for threatened coho salmon and is considered one of the most
robust in the state. Yet even here, coho have been reduced from an estimated
6000 in the 1940's to a mere 500 - a decline of 90%. This greatly reduced
run represents approximately 10% of California's remaining coho salmon.
In the 1940s, the California coho salmon population was estimated between
50,000-125,000 spawning fish per year. Today, the population has dwindled to
around 6,000. Coho have more stringent habitat requirements than the more
widespread and abundant chinook salmon, since juveniles need to rear in
cool, shaded water for at least a year before migrating to sea. Coho are now
listed as "threatened" under California law and "endangered" under the
federal Endangered Species Act.
Walder had no current estimate for the adult steelhead population, other
than saying they have a "significance" presence in the creek, due to the
difficulty of counting them during their brief migration.
The study prioritized which barriers are blocking the most habitat and
estimated the cost of repair, so conservationists can use the limited
resources that may become available as effectively as possible to get the
"most bang for the buck," added Walder.
The repairs recommended in the study range greatly in the projected cost.
Simpler repairs, such as creating a route for juvenile fish to get
downstream, could cost under $15,000. Other more complex projects, such as
removing culverts and replacing with fish-friendly structures, would cost up
to $500,000 each. Because of the complexity and varied nature of the
projects recommended, Waller didn't have an overall price tag on the
repairs.
"If we can muster the resources and political support to repair or replace
all these migration barriers, we can open up more than 4.5 miles of habitat
that have been completely or partially lost to the fish," commented Todd
Steiner, director of SPAWN and one of the authors of the report. "This will
go along way toward restoring these fish that have been assaulted by loss of
habitat, reduction of water, pollution, logging and development pressures."
Walder and Steiner are counting on the strong support of local citizens and
landowners to convince state and local politicians to push for the needed
funds. "We plan to go after a wide variety of sources for funds, including
CalTrans, Marin County and private homeowners," Walder stated.
Marin Municipal Water District customers shouldn't worry about decreasing
drinking water supplies, since the report does not address removing large
water supply dams, such as Peter's Dam on Lagunitas Creek creating Kent Lake
and Seeger on Nicasio Creek creating Nicasio Reservoir. The report
recommends the removal of small dams and culverts that either no longer
serve any functional purpose or can be replaced with fish friendly
technology.
"Some of these barriers are small dams that were built decades ago, when the
area was largely rural. They were probably used to water livestock, and
serve no purpose today," said Walder. "Other barriers, such as culverts that
allow the creeks to flow under roads, can easily be replaced by newer
designs that allow fish passage."
In a complementary effort, Marin County is conducting a similar study of
culvert crossings in additional watersheds of Lagunitas Creek.
The efforts of SPAWN, a non-profit organization that is working to protect
and restore the salmon and steelhead of Marin County, should be supported by
every angler interested in the recovery of the once abundant coho salmon and
steelhead of Lagunitas. The complete study can be obtained by downloading it
from SPAWN's website, www.spawnusa.org, or by emailing a request to
spawn@spawnusa.org. For more information, call (415) 488-0370 x102 or fax (415) 488-0372.
More Editorials by Dan