
Do you want to go to a low elevation lake that features catfish or go to a high mountain lake that holds trout?
You don’t have to make that choice at Lake Valley Reservoir, situated on the North Fork of the American River near Yuba Gap. That’s because quality fishing for both rainbow trout and brown bullhead catfish is available amidst solitude and stunning northern Sierra Nevada scenery.
Set amidst a boulder-strewn shoreline surrounded by a thick conifer forest, the lake is a haven for bank anglers, kayak fishermen and trollers. Unlike many reservoirs, motorized fishing boats are restricted to a 10-mph limit, so you won’t find any water skiers or personal watercraft users speeding around the lake. It is one of my favorite reservoirs in the Sierra Nevada and its proximity to Interstate 80 makes it an ideal location to fish when I want to get away for an afternoon of fishing.
On Labor Day weekend, 2016, the fishing wasn’t hot, but anglers still caught holdover rainbows and some feisty brown bullheads during a short afternoon trip that I made to Lake Valley. I caught and released a fat and healthy catfish weighing over 1 pound while soaking a gob of nightcrawler near the boat ramp.
Meanwhile, Joshua of Sacramento and his two fishing buddies landed two holdover rainbows and lost a larger fish while soaking PowerBait near the dam. Two trollers also reported catching and releasing two catfish.
Earlier this summer, Brian Garcia found excellent catfish action while shore fishing with nightcrawlers on the lake. He said he wanted to see if he could get trout but ended up catching 7 catfish up to 13 inches. He also lost some other fish and missed numerous bites.
Rainbow trout are the only species of fish that the California Department of Fish and Wildlife currently plants at Lake Valley. The Department most years stocks around 4,000 pounds of fish.